Orchard Towers death: 4 years 9 months' jail for last man facing non-capital charge

SINGAPORE - The last man facing a non-capital charge in the fatal 2019 Orchard Towers brawl was jailed four years and nine months and given 12 strokes of the cane on Friday (5 March).


Apart from pleading guilty to a charge of consorting with a person armed with a weapon, Tan Hong Sheng, 23, had also admitted to charges of rioting and rioting with a deadly weapon in earlier incidents, which occurred on 18 November 2018 and 27 April 2019. Both charges involve him getting into fights at clubs after drinking.


Another five charges, two of which involve causing hurt to others after he was released on bail for the Orchard Towers incident, were taken into consideration for his sentencing.


Tan, 23, was one of the seven who were initially charged with murder with common intention of 31-year-old Satheesh Noel Gobidass at the entrance of Orchard Towers on 2 July 2019.


About a week later, his charge was downgraded to consorting with co-accused Tan Sen Yang, who was carrying a Karambit knife in a public place.


Only Tan Seng Yang still faces a murder charge. Besides Tan Hong Sheng, five others – Joel Tan Yun Sheng, Ang Da Yuan, Natalie Siow, Chan Jia Xing, and Loo Boon Chong – have been dealt with. All were given jail terms except Chan, who was given a conditional warning.


In a previous hearing, the prosecution sought 60 months’ jail and 12 strokes of the cane for Tan Hong Sheng, while his lawyers Josephus Tan and Cory Wong from Invictus Law, sought 45 to 50 months’ jail, along with nine to 12 strokes of the cane.


The defence lawyers cited closed-circuit television footage and stated that Tan was calm and had “demonstrated both restraint and composure during the entire Naughty Girl Club incident” unlike Sen Yang, Ang and Siow, whom had participated in the brawl.


However the prosecution pointed out that Tan had a criminal record involving the same nature of offences for which he was convicted for in 2011, 2014 and 2016. He was given probation and reformative training sentences for those offences.


Background of Orchard Towers brawl and death

On the wee hours of 2 July 2019, Tan Hong Sheng went to several clubs to drink before ending up at Naughty Girl Club at the second floor of Orchard Towers. He was in the same group as Tan Sen Yang, whom he had known for only a month through a mutual friend.


In past drinking sessions, Tan had seen Sen Yang behaving aggressively while wielding a karambit knife. He had told his mutual friend that he did not want to meet when Sen Yang was present. However, he still went ahead with the outing on 2 July despite his friend inviting Sen Yang.


At about 6.20 am, as the group left the club, a dispute arose between them and another group of patrons at the club entrance. Tan saw that Tan Sen Yang was armed with the Karambit knife. In the resulting fray, two were injured by Tan Sen Yang, a security officer and a patron.


Tan did not attack anyone and had pulled Tan Sen Yang away from the other group to take the lift to the ground floor.


As Tan's group headed to the building entrance, Satheesh, who had also been present at the Naughty Girl Club during the dispute, confronted one member of the group. Others retaliated by attacking him. One of them was Tan Sen Yang, who punched Satheesh with the knife in his right hand and inflicted multiple injuries to his head and neck.


Tan did not join the attack and eventually pulled Sen Yang away to stop the fight. As Tan left, he saw Satheesh collapse at the entrance of Orchard Towers.


He took a cab with a few others, including Sen Yang, to Boon Lay Market and Food Centre, and later discussed the altercation there with the others.


During the exchange, Sen Yang told them not to worry as he would take responsibility. He then left with a friend while Tan remained at Boon Lay Market.


Separately, on 18 November 2018, Tan was at Club V5 at Ming Arcade with other friends when he attacked a man who had bumped into his shoulder and later stared at him. The group had assaulted the victim with a glass Martell bottle.


On 27 April 2019, at Club District 9 at Orchard Hotel, he joined his friends in assaulting another man. One of Tan’s friends had wanted to teach the victim a lesson for stealing his ex-girlfriend.

乌节大厦死亡:最后一名面临非资本罪名的男子被判入狱4年9个月

新加坡-最后一名在2019年致命的Orchard Towers斗殴中面临非死罪指控的男子被判处四年零九个月的监禁,并于周五(3月5日)被判处12次中风。

23岁的谭宏生除了承认与一名携带武器的人结伙的罪名外,还承认在早些时候的事件中发生暴动和使用致命武器暴动的指控,这些事件发生在2018年11月18日和2019年4月27日两项指控都涉及他饮酒后进入俱乐部打架。

他的判决还考虑了另外五项指控,其中两项涉及在他因乌节塔事件而被保释后对他人造成伤害。

23岁的谭(Tan)是最初被指控谋杀的七人之一,他的意图是在2019年7月2日在乌节塔(Orchard Towers)入口处谋杀31岁的萨西什·诺埃尔·戈比达斯(Satheesh Noel Gobidass)。

大约一周后,他的指控被降级为与在公共场所携带一把卡拉姆特刀的同案被告谭森杨(Tan Sen Yang)相辅相成。

只有谭成阳仍然面临谋杀罪。除谭洪升外,还有另外五个人-乔尔·谭允胜,昂达渊,娜塔莉·萧,陈家星和卢文冲–被处决。除陈某受到有条件警告外,其他所有人都被判入狱。

在先前的听证会上,检方要求谭宏生判处60个月监禁和12拐杖的拐杖,而Invictus Law的律师Josephus Tan和Cory Wong则被判处45至50个月监禁,以及9至12招的拐杖。甘蔗。

辩护律师援引了闭路电视录像,并说,谭很冷静,“在整个顽皮女童俱乐部事件中都表现出克制和镇定”,这与参战的杨森,昂和西奥不同。

然而,检方指出,谭有犯罪记录,涉及与他在2011年,2014年和2016年被定罪的罪行性质相同。他被判处这些罪行的缓刑和改革培训刑罚。

果园塔争吵和死亡的背景

在2019年7月2日凌晨,Tan Hong Sheng去了几家俱乐部喝酒,然后在果园塔二楼的Naughty Girl Club结束活动。他与谭森阳同在一个小组中,通过一个共同的朋友认识他仅一个月。

在过去的饮酒课中,Tan看到Sen Yang挥舞着一把karambit刀时表现出攻击性。他已经告诉自己的共同朋友,他不想在森阳在场时见面。然而,尽管他的朋友邀请了杨森,他仍然在7月2日进行了郊游。

当他们离开俱乐部时,大约是上午6.20,他们与俱乐部入口处的另一位顾客之间发生了争执。Tan看到Tan Sen Yang手持Karambit刀。在这场争执中,有两名是由保安员兼赞助人谭森阳(Tan Sen Yang)受伤的。

Tan并未袭击任何人,而是将Tan Sen Yang从另一组中拉开,将电梯抬至地面。

当Tan的小组前往大楼入口时,在争端期间也曾出现在Naughty Girl Club的Satheesh遇到了该小组的一名成员。其他人则通过攻击他进行报复。其中一位是Tan Sen Yang,他用右手的刀子将Satheesh击打,并造成头部和颈部多处受伤。

谭没有参加袭击,最终将森扬撤离以阻止战斗。Tan离开时,他看到Satheesh在果园塔的入口处倒塌了。

他和包括森阳在内的其他一些人搭出租车到文礼市场和食品中心,后来与其他人讨论了争执。

交流期间,杨森告诉他们不要担心,因为他会承担责任。然后,他与一位朋友一起离开,而Tan仍留在Boon Lay Market。

另外,2018年11月18日,Tan与其他朋友一起在Ming Arcade的V5俱乐部,袭击了一个撞到他肩膀上的男人,后来盯着他看。该组织用马爹利玻璃瓶殴打了受害者。

2019年4月27日,在乌节饭店9区俱乐部,他和他的朋友一起殴打了另一个男人。谭(Tan)的一位朋友曾想为受害人偷走他的前女友一堂课。


点赞(0) 打赏

评论列表 共有 0 条评论

暂无评论

热门产品

历史上的今天:03月29日

热门专题

云南巨榕教育投资集团有限公司|云南巨榕教育投资集团有限公司,巨榕教育集团,巨榕教育
云南巨榕教育投资集团有限公司
昆明网站建设|昆明网站建设,昆明网站开发,昆明网站建设公司,昆明网站建设价格,昆明网站设计,昆明网站制作,网页设计,高端网站建设,高端网站设计
昆明网站建设
外贸网站建设|外贸网站建设,英文网站制作,英文网站设计,美国主机空间,外贸建站平台,多语言网站制作
外贸网站建设
弥勒综合高中|弥勒综合高中
弥勒综合高中
大理科技管理学校|大理科技管理中等职业技术学校,大理市科技管理中等职业技术学校
大理科技管理学校
小程序开发|微信小程序,小程序开发,小程序,小程序制作,微信小程序开发,小程序公司,小程序开发公司,分销,三级分销系统,分销系统
小程序开发
一年制中专|中专学历,中专是什么学历,中专是什么,中专有什么专业,中专升大专,一年制中专
一年制中专
云南综合高中|云南综合高中
云南综合高中

微信小程序

微信扫一扫体验

立即
投稿

微信公众账号

微信扫一扫加关注

发表
评论
返回
顶部